Re: Re: [cctld-discuss] ccNSO membership applications.
Nigel, On 01.09.2003 15:49 Nigel Roberts <firstname.lastname@example.org> wrote: > > The application form signs you up not just to the 'limited number of global > policies' but to /ICANN's/ by laws. The Board could in the future adopt > by-laws > and a ccTLD manager would be bound by them This is _precisely_ the point: The ICANN board can change the bylaws anytime without even asking the ccTLDs and with that get rid of the whole ccPDP. Since they have agreed to be bound by the ICANN bylaws, the ccNSO members would then be bound to whatever rule the ICANN board chooses to replace the ccPDP with (which would probably be: "The members of the ccNSO are bound by whatever policy the ICANN board implements."). And before any supporter of the ccNSO in its current form answers to this remark: I know already what the answer would be, as we keep hearing it whenever concerns with regard to the ccNSO are being expressed: "Well, if you don't like it, you can leave." Technically, that's obviously right. But in fact one might find it impossible to leave, be it for legal reasons, or be it on the basis of political considerations - or be it even due to some pressure from ICANN itself. Besides, I wonder why a registry would join an organization in the first place when the only argument for doing so seems to be the fact that the registry can later leave this organisation. Best, Stephan